The strongest form of Platonism a physicist has published

Tegmark begins from the “unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics” and takes the shortest possible explanation: mathematics describes reality perfectly because reality is mathematics. If so, every consistent mathematical structure is a physical universe, and ours has no special status beyond being one we can inhabit.

Tegmark is an MIT cosmologist, and the paper appeared in a peer-reviewed physics journal — which is why standing here reflects the kind of claim, not the author’s credentials. Peer review does not convert a metaphysical thesis into a testable one.

The objections that bite

Gödel is the sharpest: if reality is a formal structure, undecidable propositions about it would have no physical answer, which is difficult to make sense of. There is also a measure problem — if all structures exist, calculating what an observer should expect to see requires a probability measure over an infinity of structures, and no agreed one exists.

Filed as philosophical: it makes no prediction distinguishing it from a universe merely well described by mathematics.

Related

• It from bit Open page: It from bit